Equipment Appraisal Process (Step-by-Step)
Heavy Equipment Appraisal puts the purpose first in every equipment appraisal process, because the purpose sets the value and who relies on the independent report.
What is the equipment appraisal process?
The equipment appraisal process is the set of steps an independent, qualified appraiser follows to reach a formal opinion of value for machinery and equipment as of a specific date. The basic steps that USPAP, the national appraisal standard, prescribes include defining the scope of work, collecting the data, applying the approaches to value, stating the conclusion and writing the report.
Independent means the appraiser has no stake in the value. Heavy Equipment Appraisal is independent and does not buy, sell, broker or auction equipment, and its fee does not depend on the value.
- Set the purpose, the value and the effective date.
- Choose a qualified appraiser.
- Agree on the scope of work, desktop or on-site.
- Send the equipment list and records.
- Inspect and identify each machine.
- Research the market.
- Apply the approaches to value and reconcile them.
- Receive the written report.
Why does the purpose of the appraisal come first?
The purpose of the appraisal comes first because it sets the intended use, the intended users and the value the report must state. The client sets the intended use, and the appraiser and client agree on it before the work begins.
The steps are the same for every purpose, but each reader looks for different answers. See our appraisals for SBA and bank loans, insurance, IRS and tax, selling a business, estates, divorce and bankruptcy.
Which value does an equipment appraisal state?
An equipment appraisal states the value its purpose calls for, such as fair market value, orderly liquidation value, forced liquidation value or replacement cost. The appraiser sets or accepts the definition of value after talking with the client about the intended use.
Fair Market Value (FMV) is the price between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither compelled to act and both informed. Orderly Liquidation Value (OLV) assumes a sale with a reasonable time to find buyers, and Forced Liquidation Value (FLV) assumes a properly advertised public auction with the seller compelled to sell immediately. Insurance work often uses replacement cost new, or replacement cost new less depreciation, which is often called actual cash value.
See FMV vs OLV vs FLV for how the three values differ.
What is the effective date of an appraisal?
The effective date of an appraisal is the date the value applies to, which is not always the date the work starts or ends. Values change over time, so every appraisal is stated as of one date. An estate appraisal, for example, can be dated in the past, as of the date of death.
How do you choose a qualified equipment appraiser?
You choose a qualified equipment appraiser by checking the appraiser’s credential, that the report is prepared to USPAP, and that the appraiser has no stake in the value. A reputable equipment appraiser holds a recognized credential, such as the Certified Machinery and Equipment Appraiser (CMEA) designation from the NEBB Institute, a certification from the Certified Appraisers Guild of America (CAGA), or an accredited designation from the American Society of Appraisers (ASA).
The NEBB Institute and CAGA certify appraisers and keep both listings public, so a lender, attorney or CPA can check the credentials before ordering appraisal services, including litigation support and expert witness work.
What does the scope of work cover?
The scope of work covers which equipment is appraised, the value and its effective date, how far the inspection goes and what data is gathered. It also names what is left out, because the scope of an appraisal may not be obvious.
Heavy Equipment Appraisal sets the scope in a written engagement letter, and the quote states a fixed fee before work starts. Your delivery clock starts when the engagement is signed and paid.
Is an equipment appraisal done desktop or on-site?
An equipment appraisal can be done desktop or on-site, depending on what the person who will rely on the report needs. USPAP does not require an inspection, but it does require the report to state whether the equipment was inspected and by whom.
A desktop appraisal works from your photos, serial plates, meter readings and records. An on-site appraisal adds an inspection of the machinery in person. We do desktop and on-site equipment appraisals nationwide.
Whether the file needs an inspection is that reader’s call. You can ask them, or introduce us and we will ask them for you. A file that requires an inspection does not get a desktop report.
What documents does an equipment appraisal need?
An equipment appraisal needs a list of each machine’s make, model, year and hours or miles. The fixed asset, depreciation or insurance schedule your business already keeps also works. Desktop appraisals also need photos of each machine’s four corners, its hour meter and its serial plate.
Serial numbers, attachments, and maintenance and repair records help the appraiser identify each machine and judge its condition.
How do you prepare equipment for an appraisal?
You prepare equipment for an appraisal by gathering the list and records, making each machine and its serial plate easy to reach, and naming someone who knows the equipment. A host who knows the machines speeds identification and supplies the condition and repair history.
Tell the appraiser which units are leased or belong to someone else, and which are kept at another location. An appraiser identifies leased equipment, and the report explains how the client’s word on it was relied on. Fresh paint does not change a machine’s physical condition, and an appraiser looks past it.
What happens during an equipment inspection?
An equipment inspection has the appraiser confirm each machine against the list, read its data plate and hour meter, photograph it and note its condition. The inspection is visual, and the appraiser also looks at attachments, modifications and how and where the machine is used. Talking with the operator or the person who maintains the machine adds what observation cannot, such as recent repairs and the service schedule.
Condition is recorded in grades. NEBB’s grades are Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor and Scrap, and a report defines the condition terms it uses. Equipment found on site but not on the list is raised with the client before it is added.
Does an appraiser test a machine’s mechanical condition?
No, an appraiser does not usually test a machine’s mechanical condition. NEBB trains its CMEA appraisers to certify value and not workability.
An inspection can note whether a machine is working, but a detailed mechanical inspection is not usually made. Reports commonly assume the equipment is in normal operating condition unless they say otherwise, and a client who needs the mechanical condition confirmed asks a qualified mechanic.
How does the appraiser research the market?
The appraiser researches the market by finding sales of similar machines first and then adjusted current listings, from auction results and dealers. Listings count only after they are adjusted, because an asking price is not a sale.
We read hours from a photo of the meter and match sales by configuration before model year. We adjust each comparable sale individually for hours, year, condition, location and attachments.
How do depreciation and remaining useful life affect value?
Depreciation and remaining useful life affect value by measuring how much of a machine’s usefulness is gone and how much is left. Depreciation is loss in value from physical wear, functional obsolescence and economic obsolescence. A machine with regular overhauls often has an effective age well below its calendar age, and its remaining useful life is the service left at that age.
What are the three approaches to value?
The three approaches to value are the sales comparison approach, the cost approach and the income approach. USPAP requires the appraiser to consider all three and to state why any approach was not used.
Heavy Equipment Appraisal usually uses the sales comparison approach, because standard machines such as excavators, motor graders and wheel loaders trade often enough to supply comparable sales. We lead with the cost approach, replacement cost new less depreciation, when a machine has no active resale market. We use the income approach only when a machine earns revenue that can be separated from the business, which is rare for heavy equipment.
How does the appraiser reconcile the approaches?
The appraiser reconciles the approaches by weighing each result by the quality of its data and how well it fits the machine, not by averaging them. A cost result well above the sales comparison result can point to depreciation the cost approach missed. The reconciled figure is the opinion of value as of the effective date, and the report explains which approaches were applied and why.
What does an equipment appraisal report contain?
An equipment appraisal report from Heavy Equipment Appraisal contains the client, the value and its definition, the as-of date, the intended users and the appraiser’s certificate. The report also states how each machine was identified and whether the machinery was inspected in person. We prepare every report to USPAP, and the certificate states that the fee did not depend on the value.
That certificate, with the comparable sales shown behind each value, is what makes the report defensible. A USPAP report also sets out the scope of work, the methodology, the data relied on and the assumptions, so a reader can see what was and was not done. USPAP has two report forms, the Appraisal Report and the Restricted Appraisal Report, which differ in detail and in who may rely on them.
How is an equipment appraisal different from a dealer quote?
The main difference between an equipment appraisal and a dealer quote is the independence of the person who gives the number. An independent appraiser has no stake in the sale and states a defined value. A dealer may buy or sell the machine, and a trade-in figure is a price at one level of trade, since a dealer buys to resell.
Book value is not market value either. Accounting depreciation spreads a machine’s cost over time and is not a valuation, so a fully depreciated machine can still have value.
How long does an equipment appraisal take?
An equipment appraisal from Heavy Equipment Appraisal takes 7 to 10 business days for a single machine at standard delivery. A fleet or an on-site appraisal gets its own delivery date, stated in the engagement letter. The number of machines, how many values are asked for and the type of equipment all affect that date.
How much does an equipment appraisal cost?
An equipment appraisal from Heavy Equipment Appraisal starts at $295 for a single machine at standard delivery, 7 to 10 business days. We also deliver in 3 to 5 business days on expedited and in 24 to 48 hours on rush. You see the fee before you pay.
We fix the fee before work starts. The report is the same at every speed. We quote a fleet or an on-site appraisal as one written fee for the whole job.
How it works
- Send what you have: the form, a list or photos. The quote comes by email the same day.
- Sign the engagement letter. Your delivery clock starts when the engagement is signed and paid.
- The report arrives by email on the date the engagement letter states.
Who does the work?
Rhett Crites, a Certified Machinery and Equipment Appraiser (CMEA), does the work, from the research and the inspection to the report. Rhett has worked as a heavy equipment appraiser since 2009 and is also a Certified Personal Property Appraiser (CAGA). We work on single machines to 400+ fleets, in all 50 states.
The credentials behind our reports:
- Certified Machinery and Equipment Appraiser (CMEA), NEBB Institute
- Certified Personal Property Appraiser, CAGA
- IRS-Qualified Appraiser
- Reports prepared to USPAP
See our qualifications and credentials, or read about the firm.
Frequently asked questions about the equipment appraisal process
What is the difference between an equipment appraisal and a business valuation?
The main difference between an equipment appraisal and a business valuation is the assets being valued. An equipment appraisal values the machines alone. A business valuation values the whole operating company, including working capital, real property and intangible assets such as goodwill.
What mistakes lower an equipment appraisal value?
Mistakes that can lower an equipment appraisal value include not listing a machine’s attachments and leaving out its maintenance records. Value depends on configuration and attachments, and complete maintenance records add value at resale. A machine sent without photos is assumed to be average for its year and hours.
When is a certified equipment appraisal required?
A certified equipment appraisal is required when the party that will rely on the value asks for one, such as a lender, a court, an insurer or the IRS. That party’s own rules decide what the report must contain. Tell us who will rely on the report in your quote request, so the report names them as intended users.
How do you get started?
You get started with an equipment appraisal from Heavy Equipment Appraisal by requesting a quote on the quote form. Tell us the equipment, what the report is for, who will rely on it, and the date you need it.
Send what you have from the list of records and photos above, and we reply with a written quote the same day.
We also take quote requests by phone at (844) 825-8283.
