Sales Comparison Approach for Equipment Appraisal

Heavy Equipment Appraisal reaches most of its independent values through the sales comparison approach, adjusting each recent sale of a similar machine for hours, condition and attachments, then weighing those sales into one value.

What do you need?

1 of 5
What should we price, and how many?

How many pieces?

Who will rely on the report?
When do you need it?
How should we complete it?

Desktop fits most. On-site when a lender, court, or insurer requires physical inspection.

Last step. Where should we send the quote?

Request sent.

Same day quotes. Every time.

What is the sales comparison approach?

The sales comparison approach is an appraisal method that values equipment from recent sales of similar machines, each adjusted for its differences, and is also called the market approach. The sales comparison approach is also known as the market data approach and rests on the principle of substitution: an informed buyer pays no more for a machine than the cost of an equally useful one. Heavy Equipment Appraisal is independent and does not buy, sell, broker or auction equipment, and its fee does not depend on the value.

Heavy Equipment Appraisal usually uses the sales comparison approach, because standard machines such as excavators, motor graders and wheel loaders trade often enough to supply comparable sales.

How does the sales comparison approach work?

The sales comparison approach works by identifying the machine, finding recent sales of similar machines, adjusting each sale for its differences and weighing the adjusted prices into one value. The premise of value, such as fair market value or orderly liquidation value, is set before the search begins, because different premises can call for different facts.

Here is how we apply it to each machine:

  1. We set the purpose of the appraisal and the definition of value with you before any research starts.
  2. We identify the machine: make, model, serial number, year, hours, configuration, attachments and condition. We read hours from a photo of the meter.
  3. We gather sales of similar machines. We put sold results first, then asking prices on current listings, and we remove duplicate listings so no machine counts twice.
  4. We test each comparable sale four ways: how comparable it is, when it sold, whether the sale was verified, and whether unusual conditions affected it.
  5. We adjust each comparable sale individually for hours, year, condition, location and attachments.
  6. We reconcile the adjusted sales into one value and check it against the cost approach.

The equipment appraisal process page covers the whole file, from the quote to the report.

Where do comparable sales come from?

Comparable sales come from the used equipment market, which is made up of used machinery dealers, auctions, and public and private sales. Appraisers also use databases of recorded sales organized by equipment category, from sources that can be checked for accuracy, and they need to know whether each sale was to a dealer, from a dealer or at auction. Each report from Heavy Equipment Appraisal lists the sources contacted and how each was used.

Is a dealer asking price a comparable sale?

A dealer asking price can serve as a comparable sale only when the listing is properly adjusted, because an asking price is not a sale. Sold prices set the lower limit of value in a steady or rising market, and current listings set the upper limit in any market.

The same machine listed by several sellers can make a market look more active than it is, so each listing is checked against the others.

What makes a comparable sale arm’s-length?

A comparable sale is arm’s-length when an independent buyer and seller deal under free market conditions, with neither one compelled to close. A sale between related parties, a forced sale or a sale on unusual terms may not reflect the market, so it is set aside or adjusted.

How are comparable sales adjusted?

Comparable sales are adjusted by changing each comparable’s price to what it would have brought if it matched the machine being appraised, one difference at a time. The adjustment goes to the comparable, never to the subject machine, so a comparable that is better than the subject is adjusted down and one that is worse is adjusted up. Each comparable is adjusted on its own before the set is compared, because averaging unadjusted prices distorts the result.

Which differences between machines get adjusted?

The differences that get adjusted include age, hours, condition, attachments and the date of the sale. Location, the type of sale and market conditions are adjusted too.

Difference Why it changes the price
Age Effective age, how old the machine’s condition and rebuilds make it, can count for more than its calendar age.
Hours Hours on the meter show how much use a machine has had, and harder use wears a machine faster.
Condition A machine in better condition, with its service records, brings more than the same model in worse condition.
Configuration and attachments Size class, setup and the attachments that go with the machine change what a buyer pays.
Location and freight A sale far away may need the cost of moving the machine taken into account.
Date of sale and market conditions Prices move with the market, so an older sale is brought to the date of the appraisal.
Type of sale A sale to a dealer, a sale from a dealer and an auction sale sit at different levels of trade.

What makes two machines comparable?

Two machines are comparable when a buyer would treat one as a substitute for the other, with the same or equal usefulness, size class and configuration. We match sales by configuration before model year.

A direct match, the same make and model, needs few adjustments beyond hours and condition and gives the most accurate indication. A comparable match, a similar machine from another maker or size, is judged by a measure of usefulness such as capacity and needs more adjustment. When neither exists, the percentage of cost technique relates the sale prices of similar machines to their cost new.

What does a sales comparison appraisal report show?

A sales comparison appraisal report from Heavy Equipment Appraisal shows how every machine was identified, its condition and its value, and the comparable sales research behind that value. The Capital Equipment schedule gives one line for every machine, and the research note under the line says how its value was reached.

Every valuation report ends with the appraiser’s certificate: the value, that the fee did not depend on it, the standard it was prepared to, and whether the machinery was inspected in person.

That certificate, with the comparable sales shown behind each value, is what makes our report defensible.

Which value do comparable sales support?

Comparable sales can support fair market value, orderly liquidation value or forced liquidation value, depending on the premise the appraisal states. Fair market value assumes a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither compelled and both informed. Orderly liquidation value assumes a compelled seller with a reasonable time to find buyers, and forced liquidation value assumes a properly advertised public sale with a sense of urgency.

A report from Heavy Equipment Appraisal states each value and its definition. For loan collateral, the value is often, though not always, a liquidation value. The FMV vs OLV vs FLV page sets the three side by side.

Is an auction result the same as fair market value?

No, an auction result is not the same as fair market value, because an auction is a method of sale, not a value premise. The main difference between an auction result and fair market value is the sale each reflects, one auction’s bidders against a willing buyer and seller, neither compelled. When the equipment is desirable and the auction is well advertised and well attended, auction prices can equal fair market value, other auctions bring prices well below it, and each auction is studied on its own.

For heavy equipment, where auction is a standard way machines change hands, auction results can carry real weight in the comparison. A comparable from an auction, a dealer’s lot or a private sale is adjusted to the level of trade the premise calls for.

How are the comparable sales reconciled into one value?

The comparable sales are reconciled into one value by weighing each adjusted sale for its closeness to the machine and its reliability, not by a simple average. A wide spread left after every adjustment is a sign that some factor affecting value was missed. The result is then checked against the cost approach, and the report explains why any approach was not used.

Our appraiser concludes each value and signs the report personally.

When does the sales comparison approach not fit?

The sales comparison approach does not fit when a machine is unique, custom-built or rarely traded, because too few verifiable sales of similar machines exist. The approach fits best for standard construction equipment that trades often, where sales are many and can be checked. A thin market for a machine can itself be a sign of weak demand or economic obsolescence.

What happens if there are no comparable sales?

If a machine has no comparable sales, Heavy Equipment Appraisal leads with the cost approach, replacement cost new less depreciation. Shop-built and one-off machines are the usual case, because nothing like them has sold. The cost approach page explains how it works.

How does the sales comparison approach differ from the cost and income approaches?

The main difference between the sales comparison approach and the cost and income approaches is the evidence each one starts from. The sales comparison approach starts from what similar machines sold for, the cost approach from what a replacement would cost new less depreciation, and the income approach from the revenue a machine earns.

Comparable sales reflect most depreciation in their prices, though some obsolescence tied to a plant or a region may not show in the used market. We use the income approach only when a machine earns revenue that can be separated from the business, which is rare for heavy equipment. The income approach page covers when it applies.

What does USPAP require of the sales comparison approach?

USPAP requires the appraiser to consider the sales comparison, cost and income approaches, and the report to explain why any approach was not used. USPAP, the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, also requires the report to state the definition of value it uses and cite the source of that definition.

We prepare every report to USPAP, the national appraisal standard. Our reports state the methods of valuation and why each approach was or was not used, and the certificate states that the fee did not depend on the value.

Which appraisals use the sales comparison approach?

Appraisals for loans, insurance, taxes, divorces and business sales use the sales comparison approach whenever the machines trade often enough to supply comparable sales. Each purpose asks for its own value and has its own page:

Who does the work?

Rhett Crites, a Certified Machinery and Equipment Appraiser (CMEA), does the work, from the research and the inspection to the report. Rhett has worked as a heavy equipment appraiser since 2009 and is also a Certified Personal Property Appraiser (CAGA). We work on single machines to 400+ fleets, in all 50 states.

The fee is fixed before work starts and never depends on the value of equipment; USPAP bars appraisers from any fee that does. No engagement is taken on the condition of reaching a number.

A file that requires an inspection does not get a desktop report.

How much does an equipment appraisal cost?

An equipment appraisal from Heavy Equipment Appraisal starts at $295 for a single machine at standard delivery, 7 to 10 business days. We also deliver in 3 to 5 business days on expedited and in 24 to 48 hours on rush. You see the fee before you pay.

We fix the fee before work starts. The report is the same at every speed. We quote a fleet or an on-site appraisal as one written fee for the whole job.

How it works

  1. Send what you have: the form, a list or photos. The quote comes by email the same day.
  2. Sign the engagement letter. Your delivery clock starts when the engagement is signed and paid.
  3. The report arrives by email on the date the engagement letter states.

See all prices and delivery times

Frequently asked questions

Does a desktop appraisal use the sales comparison approach?

Yes, a desktop appraisal uses the sales comparison approach the same way an on-site appraisal does, because the comparable sales are researched from sale records, not inspected. The difference is how the machine being appraised is identified, from your photos and records or in person. We do desktop and on-site equipment appraisals nationwide, and the desktop or on-site page covers which one a file needs.

How many comparable sales does an equipment appraisal need?

An equipment appraisal needs no set number of comparable sales, only enough verified sales to support its value. Heavy Equipment Appraisal’s reports typically weigh about ten verified sales of the same or a close model for each machine. Our report shows the comparable sales behind each value, so a reader can see what the value rests on.

What should you send for a sales comparison appraisal?

You should send a list of the machines for a sales comparison appraisal, with photos of each machine, its serial plate and its hour meter. The list gives each machine’s make, model, serial number, year and hours, and repair records and purchase prices are useful too.

How is the sales comparison approach different for equipment than for real estate?

The main difference between the sales comparison approach for equipment and for real estate is whether the appraiser inspects the comparables. Unlike in real estate appraisal, an equipment appraiser generally does not inspect each comparable machine, because the machines appraised are many and the sales come from a wide area. Equipment comparables are checked instead through reliable sale records that show how each machine was sold.

How do you get started?

You get started with an equipment appraisal from Heavy Equipment Appraisal by requesting a quote on the quote form. Tell us the equipment, what the report is for, who will rely on it, and the date you need it.

We also take quote requests by phone at (844) 825-8283.

Start your appraisal quote

Four answers start a quote for equipment appraisal services, desktop or on-site: who you are, the machine, who will rely on the report, and the date. The quote comes by email the same day.

Start your quote