Forced Liquidation Value Equipment Appraisal
Heavy Equipment Appraisal figures forced liquidation value by assuming the equipment must sell now at a properly advertised public auction, and the firm stays independent of any such sale.
What is a forced liquidation value appraisal?
A forced liquidation value (FLV) appraisal is an independent, USPAP-compliant opinion of the gross amount equipment could typically bring at a properly advertised and conducted public auction. The seller is compelled to sell with a sense of immediacy, as-is, where-is, as of a specific date.
Independent here means the appraiser has no stake in the sale or its result. Heavy Equipment Appraisal is independent and does not buy, sell, broker or auction equipment, and its fee does not depend on the value.
NEBB’s training calls a forced liquidation a quick sale, and people also search for it as forced sale value. The American Society of Appraisers’ text and NEBB’s training give the same definition, and when our report states forced liquidation value, it prints the definition with its source.
What does forced liquidation value assume about the sale?
Forced liquidation value assumes a quick but proper public sale, with a seller who must sell. The definition has five parts:
- A gross amount. The value is what the sale brings, before any costs of the sale come out.
- A properly advertised and conducted public auction. The sale is still marketed to buyers.
- A seller compelled to sell with a sense of immediacy. The time to find a buyer is shorter than for orderly liquidation value. The appraiser sets that period for each file from market evidence, and the report states it with its basis.
- As-is, where-is. The machine sells in its current condition, where it sits. The buyer usually pays to take it apart and remove it.
- A specific date. The value holds as of one stated date.
Why is forced liquidation value lower than orderly liquidation value and fair market value?
Forced liquidation value is usually lower than orderly liquidation value and fair market value because it gives the seller the least time to sell. Fair market value assumes a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither compelled.
Every liquidation value assumes a compelled seller. Orderly liquidation value allows a reasonable time to find a buyer, while forced liquidation value allows only a sense of immediacy. Exposure time, how long a machine is on the market before it sells, is the essential difference between the two liquidation values.
FMV, OLV and FLV side by side shows how the three compare and which one a file needs.
Is forced liquidation value the same as salvage or scrap value?
No, forced liquidation value is not the same as salvage or scrap value. The main difference is what the buyer is paying for. Salvage value is what a machine or part retired from service may bring for possible use elsewhere, and scrap value is what it would bring for its material content alone.
Both salvage value and scrap value usually sit below forced liquidation value.
Why would a lender or trustee ask for forced liquidation value?
A lender or trustee asks for forced liquidation value to learn what equipment would bring in a rushed sale, such as one after a loan default. Whoever asked for the report usually names the value, and if nobody has, the quote recommends one. Common files include:
- A lender’s collateral review. To protect a loan in case of default, a lender often, though not necessarily, bases the appraised value on a liquidation value, what a distress sale would recover.
- A bankruptcy case. Creditors in a bankruptcy case usually prefer to be paid in cash, not equipment, so a liquidation value is often the right one when the equipment will be sold. When counsel asks for an auction value, we use orderly liquidation value unless counsel needs forced liquidation value. See bankruptcy equipment appraisals.
- A repossession or other creditor’s sale. A bankruptcy court ruling, a leasing company, a bank or another note holder can force the owner to sell.
- A sale where everything must go now. All items go to auction and must sell now.
How does an appraiser reach forced liquidation value for equipment?
An appraiser reaches forced liquidation value for equipment by studying what comparable machines brought in sales made under similar pressure, examining the circumstances of each sale and adjusting each comparable. Each machine is first identified by make, model and serial number. The adjustments cover differences in age, hours, condition, capacity, configuration and location, and the date of each sale.
Heavy Equipment Appraisal usually uses the sales comparison approach, because standard machines such as excavators, motor graders and wheel loaders trade often enough to supply comparable sales. We lead with the cost approach, replacement cost new less depreciation, when a machine has no active resale market. We use the income approach only when a machine earns revenue that can be separated from the business, which is rare for heavy equipment.
Is an auction result the same as forced liquidation value?
An auction result can be the same as forced liquidation value when its bids reflect a compelled sale with a sense of immediacy. An auction is a method of sale, not a value premise, so the appraiser studies the circumstances of each sale first.
With good advertising, wanted equipment and high attendance, auction prices can equal fair market value, and at other times they fall well below it. For excavators, dozers and loaders, auction is usually a standard way to sell, so results can sit nearer orderly liquidation value. The appraiser makes that call for each file.
Is forced liquidation value a fixed percentage of fair market value?
No, forced liquidation value is not a fixed percentage of fair market value. Each level of value is its own study of the machine’s market, not a discount taken off another value.
NEBB training makes the same point: how much less a machine would bring at auction cannot be said without a study of liquidation value.
What is the difference between gross and net forced liquidation value?
The main difference between gross and net forced liquidation value is the cost of the sale. Forced liquidation value as defined is a gross amount. In collateral appraisal practice, a net value takes out the expenses of conducting and concluding a liquidation sale, such as commissions and advertising.
When our report states forced liquidation value, it states it as its definition gives it, a gross amount.
What lowers or raises forced liquidation value?
Forced liquidation value depends on the buyers at the sale, how the equipment usually sells, removal work, modifications and how many like units are for sale. In more detail:
- The buyers who can reach the sale. A dealer buying to resell pays at a different level than an end user who needs the machine.
- How that kind of equipment usually sells. Where auction is the normal way an industry sells its equipment, auction results can reach orderly liquidation value or even fair market value.
- Where the machine sits and the work to remove it. For financing at forced liquidation value, its location in a facility and the effort to remove it may change the value.
- Modifications. A change that adds value under a fair value premise can take value away from forced liquidation value.
- How many like machines are for sale. Many comparable units on the market at the same time can depress prices.
Does forced liquidation value differ for construction equipment and CNC machines?
Yes, forced liquidation value differs for construction equipment and CNC machines because they usually sell in different ways. General-use construction machines such as excavators, dozers and loaders usually sell to end-user contractors, dealers and national auctions, and trucks sell to on-road buyers.
Shop and plant machinery, such as CNC machines, is often valued in place, and for forced liquidation value its location in the building and the work to remove it can change the value. Foundations, wiring and other installation items are usually left out of a forced liquidation value.
What does a forced liquidation value report state?
A forced liquidation value report from Heavy Equipment Appraisal states each machine’s forced liquidation value as of one stated date, with the definition and its source printed. It names who may rely on the report, states the selling period the value assumes and its basis, says how each machine was identified and whether it was inspected in person, and ends with the appraiser’s certificate.
One report can state forced liquidation value beside fair market value and orderly liquidation value, each to its own definition. We prepare every report to USPAP, the national appraisal standard. The certificate states that the fee did not depend on the value.
How much does a forced liquidation value equipment appraisal cost?
A forced liquidation value equipment appraisal from Heavy Equipment Appraisal starts at $295 for a single machine at standard delivery, 7 to 10 business days. We also deliver in 3 to 5 business days on expedited and in 24 to 48 hours on rush. You see the fee before you pay.
We fix the fee before work starts. The report is the same at every speed. We quote a fleet or an on-site appraisal as one written fee for the whole job.
How it works
- Send what you have: the form, a list or photos. The quote comes by email the same day.
- Sign the engagement letter. Your delivery clock starts when the engagement is signed and paid.
- The report arrives by email on the date the engagement letter states.
Who does the work?
Rhett Crites, a Certified Machinery and Equipment Appraiser (CMEA), does the work, from the research and the inspection to the report. Rhett has worked as a heavy equipment appraiser since 2009 and is also a Certified Personal Property Appraiser (CAGA). We work on single machines to 400+ fleets, in all 50 states.
The fee is fixed before work starts and never depends on the value of equipment; USPAP bars appraisers from any fee that does. No engagement is taken on the condition of reaching a number.
The NEBB Institute and CAGA certify appraisers and keep both listings public, so a lender, attorney or CPA can check the credentials before ordering appraisal services, including litigation support and expert witness work.
A reputable equipment appraiser holds a recognized credential, such as the Certified Machinery and Equipment Appraiser (CMEA) designation from the NEBB Institute, a certification from the Certified Appraisers Guild of America (CAGA), or an accredited designation from the American Society of Appraisers (ASA).
The credentials behind our reports:
- Certified Machinery and Equipment Appraiser (CMEA), NEBB Institute
- Certified Personal Property Appraiser, CAGA
- IRS-Qualified Appraiser
- Reports prepared to USPAP
What are the frequently asked questions about forced liquidation value?
What do you send for a forced liquidation value appraisal?
You send an equipment list with each machine’s make, model, serial number, year and hours for a forced liquidation value appraisal. Photographs, serial plates, meter readings and records help.
Tell us who will rely on the report and what it is for.
Can a low forced liquidation value be challenged?
Yes, a low forced liquidation value can be challenged on documented factual errors and evidence, sent in writing through the party that ordered the report. A value lower than you expected is not a ground by itself, because a dispute has to show where the report went wrong.
Check the definition of value and its source, the as-of date and the comparable sales. A forced liquidation value used where fair market value belongs is usually far lower.
Does a forced liquidation value appraisal need an on-site inspection?
A forced liquidation value appraisal needs an on-site inspection only when the lender, trustee or counsel relying on it requires one. We do desktop and on-site equipment appraisals nationwide. A file that requires an inspection does not get a desktop report.
You can ask them whether the file calls for an on-site inspection, or introduce us and we will ask them for you.
How do you get started?
You get started with a forced liquidation value equipment appraisal from Heavy Equipment Appraisal by requesting a quote on the quote form. Tell us the equipment, whether the report is for a loan, a bankruptcy or a repossession, who will rely on it, and the date you need it.
Send what you have from the list of records and photos above, and we reply with a written quote the same day.
We also take quote requests by phone at (844) 825-8283.
